AGUEST SAID
Good morning and peace to you all, especially YOU, dear, dear Char! Please know that I certainly knew you meant no offense! I hope my "zealous" response didn't offend YOU - as I've stated, this is a topic very near and dear to my heart... for several reasons, including the utter falsity of the WTBTS' teaching about... and covert prohibitions and attempts to undermine... it. I must stop myself from calling them "despicable" for it, so as not the offend the MOST Holy One of Israel, JAH of Armies, Himself! But it is difficult sometimes... because of its motives and purpose: to shut UP the kingdom of the heavens before these poor folks!
You've given me two posts that contain comments I'd like to respond to if I may - thank you VERY much, dear one!
Quote:
Quote:
There are so very many alternatives. For instance, here in the UK, you can go into almost any denomination of Protestant church and the invitation to take part in Holy Communion is extended to all visitors from any other denomination. The only church in which this doesn't happen is the RC church, but that's for particular reasons and nothing to do with the universality of the invitation. (Not the context to go into that here and now.)
I understand as to not going into the RC context just now. As for the others, these before whom I wish to declare my union with Christ... as well as demonstrate what THEY should do in order to put themselves in line for union... are not in these other places. As your comment suggests, those in such places ALREADY KNOW. How in the world, though, will those still in that WTBTS harlot... if no one goes TO them? MUST we wait for them to come OUT? That would be like saying JAH didn't need to send His angels into Sodom, but only wait until Lot "got it" and came OUT in order to lead him to safety? Where, though, is the LOVE... in that??
Quote:
Quote:
I thought the same would be so in other countries. Is that not so?
It is, dear one... but, again, what would be the purpose? I don't need to go to ANY church/religion to declare my union with Christ - I AM the "church", a LIVING stone in the temple of God. And so I can well partake at home... alone, with my family, loved ones... or at another's home, etc., for that. But my declaration is BEFORE these, those in the WTBTS. And they would never come to my home to see it... would they?
Quote:
Quote:
Also, if I have understood you all correctly these last few months, most or at least many of you share a belief in the validity of private commemorations of your own, so why not do that?
I DO do that, dear one... every day. Just as Israel did while still in the wilderness. I declare the death of my dear Lord every single day... and will do so until he returns. This, though, is not about that... as much as it is about making that declaration before men.
Quote:
Quote:
I just don't understand why anyone would want to go back to a KH for it...nor even why you would participate in Christ's gift just once a year, when that in itself means inherent acceptance of the WT's own twisted interpretation.
But it does NOT mean that, dear one, not at ALL! It means that I do NOT accept their twisted interpretation. If I went and did NOT partake... THAT would mean acceptance of their interpretation. For me to go and partake... PUBLICLY... means I am PUBLICLY declaring that I AM in union with Christ... BEFORE these who say I am NOT... and that I DO what HE said... NOT them... which I declare BEFORE them... publicly.
Quote:
Quote:
on the subject of confession.
Yes, which I hope you can now understand is to ME... in the way your faith calls for it, EXACTLY the same thing as my public declaration of my union with Christ may be to YOU. I don't understand why you feel you must do what you feel YOU must do... but perhaps it's not FOR me to understand, but only YOU.
Quote:
Quote:
Just as I can see that my own puzzlement, as I expressed it last night, is born of my inadequate understanding of the JW position...I tend to forget for how long and how thoroughly so many of you were immersed in the WT ...so your view of so much that is part of the R.C. Church springs likewise from insufficient understanding.
That could be, dear one, but I need to clarify that I was not born into that organization - I entered as an adult. And so I had some things established long before I ever knew what a Jehovah's Witness was. Which might be one reason why I am more compelled than some others: I don't have ANY fear of her. I have no one "still inside" her, or anyone that I am concerned with embarassing or humiliating. Not that that would deter me: I would rather face their chagrin, even anger... than my Lord's disappointment.
Quote:
Quote:
You described beautifully the common misunderstanding of the sacrament of confession. You're quite correct. The only person to whom we should confess is God. You understand and believe that, and so do I. So does the Catholic Church. The only person we DO confess to is God, and you might think that all we need to do is just say sorry to God, and that's true! The Church too teaches exactly that! And every Catholic child is taught that too!
I am glad we see the same on this, dear one!
Quote:
Quote:
You have in your mind that when a person goes through the process of Confession they go into that box you see in the films and they are telling the priest. It looks like that, doesn't it? But the person they are talking to is Christ. In this particular instance, though, they are doing so aloud, THROUGH the person of the priest. They speak TO Christ THROUGH the priest.
And that is a problem for me, dear one... one that I can't understand why isn't a problem for you. Why would I need to speak to Christ THROUGH ANYONE?? Why can't I go directly to HIM? I mean... I CAN. So WHY go "through" anyone else? The ONLY person I need to "go through" to as to speak to or be heard by another... is through Christ so as to speak to/be heard by God. Otherwise, there is NO OTHER. That you consider going through another man to speak to Christ is... well, a lot of things to me, actually, but none of them good. Even so... YOUR understanding allows you to do so. I am not your judge, however, nor do you owe me an explanation. So, while I can ask you to explain... if I truly WANT to know... and love would prompt me to ACCEPT that explanation, even if I didn't UNDERSTAND it... I cannot come to you demanding an explanation simply because I don't understand it. Right? Because you don't OWE me an explanation. You only owe me... love. Right?
Quote:
Quote:
"Oh!" You probably say, "they don't need to do that, they only need to tell God inside their head, privately."
Actually, I would not say that, dear one. Not at all. Rather, while I would say that, yes, one could perhaps "speak" with CHRIST silently... my understanding is that words to the Father should be out loud. Else, why even go INTO one's private room... shut the door... and THEN pray? My understanding is the reason for this is so that others DON'T hear your prayer... because it is between you and the Father, alone. Many pray out loud, in front of others... but that is so as to be heard BY others. Christ said that WE are NOT to do that, though. If, however, one can simply pray to the Father in their head... why go into one's private room at all? So that one can bow their head/get on their knees? Where, though, did Christ say THAT was necessary in order to pray to the Father?
The ONLY requirements I know of are to do so in private... and through him (Christ). Not necessarily on bended knee... and certainly not through any other person. Of course, if the circumstances dictate that one cannot get away TO pray in private, then one can offer a silent prayer, yes, but that's an exception (Nehemiah 1:4-11; 2:4b. My Lord himself ALWAYS prayed to the Father... out loud. It was for this reason that he often separated himself (with perhaps 1-2 exceptions - John 17:1)from his disciples... and for some distance... so that he COULD pray in private (Matthew 26:36, 42, 44; Mark 14:32-35, 39; Luke 22:41)... because he didn't have his own private room to use (. Why separate himself if he could just pray in silence?
Quote:
Quote:
True. That's the most important thing, and that's what they DO do...FIRST. That's all they HAVE to do. BUT not everyone finds that easy, and not everyone has the insight to understand themselves and their own heart. Many people, indeed, condemn themselves and suffer agonies of totally unnecessary guilt, either for things they needn't blame themselves for or things they can't forgive themselves for. That's why psychiatrists do such a roaring trade!
But if such ones simply went to CHRIST they wouldn't even have to pay! No donation/contribution, no priests to "keep", no psychiatrist bill(s), right? But these are necessary due to what? A LACK OF FAITH. And so they are not sanctioned by God, dear one. They belong to the WORLD, which remains in darkness (BECAUSE of that lack of faith)... rather than in the Light! Right? Who... or what... should man EVER turn to for answers... assistance... comfort... guidance... direction... instruction... help... EXCEPT Christ? Nothing... and no one. So these CAN'T be sanctioned by God, the One who ESTABLISHED Christ as that One. Right?
Quote:
Quote:
The priest assures the person of the totality of God's forgiveness. When a person has gone through the ritual of confessing through a priest, he KNOWS he is forgiven.
But Char... such one ISN'T forgiven... any more than Israel was by the priests they took THEIR sacrifices to! Only GOD can forgive... and so the only others than can do so are those who are granted AUTHORITY to forgive BY God. They are those who RECEIVE that authority... by means of holy spirit!... from CHRIST, the One to whom God has granted ALL authority. And so while these people may THINK they are forgiven... their sins remain! Why? Because, by going to the ones they ARE... they are "climbing up some OTHER way"... rather than going through the DOOR! (
John 10:1, 7-9)
Now, I don't understand why anyone would want to DO that... but it is not MY place to judge them (because JAH shows mercy to whomever HE wishes). Nor can I say to YOU... "Why would you DO that??!" I absolutely would not... but I am not you.
Quote:
Quote:
The priest hasn't forgiven him. God did that, Christ did that before he ever began that process. God forgives us the moment we are truly sorry.
This is not true, dear one. We are forgiven if and when we ASK for forgiveness ON THE BASIS of Christ's blood. Because "unless blood is poured out there is NO forgiveness of sins." (Hebrews 9:22) So, if one is not IN UNION with Christ, which not only includes partaking of his flesh and blood... and OBEYING his commandments TO such one, INDIVIDUALLY... as well as doing the Father's will... and one does not ASK... how is one to RECEIVE forgiveness??
Quote:
Quote:
But, especially for those who have a hard time forgiving themselves, once they've gone through that process, they KNOW, deep down in their heart, they're forgiven.
They know they've been forgiven by man. But that does NOT mean they've been forgiven by God. And vice versa. And... can one who has not been forgiven himself/herself FORGIVE sins against God? For example, if I am a hypocrite, living a life where, say, I secretly kill others... can I forgive the sins of others before God? Does not a LITTLE "leaven" ferment the entire lump, so that the entire lump is unclean?
Quote:
Quote:
There is a profound experience of great joy and release. Also, the priest is unshockable and very experienced, and can often give very good advice.
But cannot Christ himself do the very same thing? If so, why, then, put someone else in his PLACE? Why not go directly to HIM... and ask forgiveness FROM him... on the basis of HIS blood... for FREE... rather than going to ANY other? I mean, do we REALLY need to SEE another man, hear his voice... so as to have faith that our sins ARE forgiven? Is that not looking/calling upon a golden calf? Or should we not simply put our faith in Christ... and HIS mercy... letting HIM tell us HIMSELF... with his OWN voice... that we are forgiven... by HIM?
Quote:
Quote:
It is very often a very very valuable healing experience, and totally, completely private. The encounter is, in every way, for both participants, with God. Naturally, as one would expect, it's been the subject of much simplification and caricature in movie after movie. Those who are Catholic understand it, and those who don't and have their own existing theological objections don't.
But then, that would be the same, would it not, as saying JWs "understand" the things they believe... and that's just as "okay," yes? If so, then how can any of US have any objections to what they believe? Dear one, there is no more basis for confessing to priests... or listening to/following... indeed, even having a Pope... than there is for not partaking... and so listening to/following... or even having... a GB.
We have a Leader. One. Christ. There is NO other, my dear, dear Char. That folks still walk by SIGHT... versus by FAITH... such that they NEED men, institutions, traditions, rituals, doctrines, etc., to see... and hear... because their lack of faith won't ALLOW them to hear... or see... Christ... doesn't make such men, institutions, traditions, rituals, doctrines... or the temporary "comfort" such might bring RIGHT. They are ALL false, dear one. Everyone one of them. Unfortunately, not everyone is able... or even READY... to see THAT truth. Yet.
Quote:
Quote:
BTW, the confession box, while it still exists in most places, is very far from being the only place it takes place. Next week our parish, like so many all over the world, will have what's called a Penitential Service, half a dozen priests will come from neighbouring parishes and will sit in various places round the church, one in the "box", one in a separate room, and the others just sitting quietly out of earshot round the church. People choose firstly if they want to go at all, and secondly where and to whom they'll go, if at all. I shall go to one who will just be sitting on a chair, with another chair next to him. He's a young man and I am a grandma! But I know him as deeply spiritual, with insight and intelligence and kindness, his advice is very sound, and he has been of immeasurable help to me in coming out of the trauma of the WT.
Ahh, now SEE: I can't imagine ever doing such a thing, going to some man, no matter how "experienced" or "compassionate" I might think he is... or in whatever setting... or however the arrangement is set up to make me feel "comfortable"... and confess my sins. Even if I personally knew such a man. Because (1) I have One to go to and I trust HIM when he tells me I am forgiven, and (2) I have no idea what's truly in the heart of such a man... or whether HIS prayer actually "gets through." He might be a man who has no more power than to pray to himself. ([b[]Luke 18:11)
Quote:
Quote:
For me, as for so many, the whole process is just another grace from a loving God. For you, with different life experience and different theological education and understanding, it's something that seems anything but. Yet here we are, I believe and am sure, the very best of dear friends! that's how I feel and how I see things. I rejoice in my faith and in yours, for we both...indeed ALL of us here... know and love God our Heavenly Father and Christ his Son.
And THAT is all that should matter, yes? True, if you believe I am heading in a wrong direction... and are COMPELLED by the Spirit to warn me, then you must do so... but in love! And vice versa: if I am compelled to warn YOU of something, then I should do so and in love. I am not so compelled toward you; however, I AM compelled to do so toward those I formerly associated with. Because of my love... and more importantly, my Lord's love... for them.
Quote:
Quote:
Oh! One last thing! Please don't think the sacrament of confession is exclusive to the RC church. Far from it. All in the Catholic tradition have the same facility. It's all done in the context of forgiveness, and has none of the punitive condemnatory culture of the Watchtower.
I do not think this (smile!). And I do understand that it is a much less punitive/condemnatory situation (if at all) than as with the WTBTS. But those in her who participate in such are, for the most part, sheep without a shepherd. Now, I can tell them about and perhaps lead them to OTHER shepherds. For example, priests of other religions. OR... I can tell them about (and perhaps, as a result, maybe lead them) to the FINE Shepherd himself. Given what I know of them... and him... I can make no other choice but to tell them about the latter... and pray for the FATHER to draw them to That One. Because MY faith is in HIM... and NO ONE else.
Dear, dear Char... please know that I do not condemn your choices; I respect them. However, they do bring up the same astonishment in ME as perhaps mine in this matter raise in you. But as long as we can receive each other with love, the Father, who is MOST Holy One of Israel, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, JAH of Armies... will Himself FINISH our training... by and through our dear Lord, His Son, the HOLY One of Israel and Holy Spirit, JAHESHUA, the Chosen One of JAH (MischaJah). I have ALL faith in that... and absolutely NO doubt.
So, I hope this helps!
Again, peace to you, dear one!
YOUR servant, sister, and fellow slave of Christ,
SA